Quick answer: Keep the driver's base rate steady and let a separate fuel surcharge line move with diesel. Tie it to a public weekly price, such as the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) diesel average, and only change it when the price crosses a set band (for example, every 10 cents). Write the baseline, the formula, and the effective date into the pay agreement before prices move. Apply every change forward from a clear date, never back onto miles already run, and show drivers the math on their statement.
Key takeaways
- A flat per-mile rate with no fuel line puts all the diesel risk on the carrier. Percentage pay moves with the freight rate, not with fuel. Neither tracks diesel by itself.
- A common surcharge formula is (current diesel price − baseline price) ÷ MPG = surcharge per mile. At 6.5 MPG, a 50-cent rise is about 7.7 cents a mile.
- On percentage pay, check what the percentage applies to: linehaul only, linehaul plus fuel surcharge, or revenue after fuel. Mixing these up is the most common fuel-related settlement error.
- When diesel falls, the surcharge falls too. That is the formula working, not a pay cut, but drivers need to see why.
- Change pay at a settlement boundary, forward only, and keep a record of the old rate, new rate, date, and who approved it.
By the numbers

- The U.S. retail diesel price averaged $6.28 a gallon in the week of Oct 19, 2026, up $2.66 (73.4%) from a year earlier. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, FRED GASDESW.
Latest official data as of Oct 24, 2026.
Step 1: Know how your pay model reacts to diesel
| Pay model | What happens when diesel rises | Who carries the cost | Usual fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat per mile | Driver pay stays the same | The carrier, on every mile | Add a fuel surcharge line |
| Percentage of linehaul | Pay follows the freight rate, not fuel | Depends on whether the customer's fuel surcharge reaches the driver | State in writing how the fuel surcharge is split |
| Percentage after fuel is deducted | Pay drops as fuel takes more of the load | Shared by carrier and driver | Consider a weekly minimum |
| Hourly | Pay follows time, not miles | The carrier | Rarely needs a surcharge |
| Base rate + fuel surcharge line | Base stays the same; the fuel line moves | Shared, by formula | This is the hybrid most fleets use |
Owner-operators who buy their own fuel are a separate case. Their agreement decides who carries fuel, so a fleet-wide adjustment can overpay one group and short another. See Owner-Operator vs Company Driver Settlement Calculations and Truck Driver Pay Models: Mileage, Percentage, Hourly, Salary.
Don't skip this: if your statements don't show base pay and the fuel line separately, you can't tell whether a bad week came from freight rates, the driver, or diesel. Split them first.

Step 2: Run your own numbers at two diesel prices
Before you change anything, see where the money goes. Example: a 500-mile loaded run, a truck at 6 MPG, a load that pays $1,800.
| Pay model | Diesel at $3.50 | Diesel at $4.50 | Change in carrier margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0.60 per mile | Fuel $292 · Driver $300 · Margin $1,208 | Fuel $375 · Driver $300 · Margin $1,125 | –$83 |
| 25% after fuel is deducted | Net after fuel $1,508 · Driver $377 · Margin $1,131 | Net after fuel $1,425 · Driver $356 · Margin $1,069 | –$62 (driver shares $21) |
Flat per-mile pay puts the whole $83 on the carrier. Percentage-after-fuel splits it. These are round numbers to show the mechanics; run your own trucks' real MPG and rates.
Also check whether the problem is really fuel. Compare cost per mile three months ago with today. If the rise tracks the diesel price, it is a fuel problem. If cost per mile is flat but revenue per mile fell, it is a freight-rate problem, and a fuel surcharge won't fix it. Our cost per mile guide shows how to build that number.
Step 3: Build the fuel surcharge
A fuel surcharge needs four things written down:
- A baseline price: the diesel price where the surcharge starts.
- A public reference: most fleets use the EIA weekly on-highway diesel price. It comes out every week, for the country and for each region. Use the region where most of your miles run.
- A band: the surcharge changes only when the price crosses a new 5- or 10-cent band, so it doesn't move every week by a penny.
- A formula and rounding rule: so anyone can check the number.
Per-MPG formula: (current price − baseline) ÷ MPG = surcharge per mile.
Baseline $3.90, current $4.40, 6.5 MPG: $0.50 ÷ 6.5 = $0.077 a mile. On 2,400 miles a week, that is about $185 for the week.
Step formula: 1 cent a mile for every 10 cents above the baseline. Baseline $3.50:
| Diesel price | Above baseline | Surcharge per mile | Base $0.58 + surcharge |
|---|---|---|---|
| $4.10 | 60¢ | 6¢ | $0.64 a mile |
| $3.70 | 20¢ | 2¢ | $0.60 a mile |
| $3.40 | below | 0¢ | $0.58 a mile |
Decide up front:
- Empty miles. If the surcharge is paid only on loaded miles, the truck still burns fuel empty. Say whether deadhead gets the surcharge, a reduced one, or none.
- Reefer fuel and idling. A per-mile surcharge doesn't cover them. Treat reefer fuel as its own line.
- Real MPG per truck. A truck at 6.2 MPG and one at 7.4 MPG get different surcharges from the same price move if the formula uses each truck's MPG. If you use one fleet number, say so.
- A cap, if you need one for budgeting, written in the agreement.
Sample clause
"Base rate is $0.58 per loaded mile. A fuel surcharge applies when the EIA Midwest weekly on-highway diesel price moves $0.10 or more from the $3.90 baseline. Surcharge per mile = (current price − $3.90) ÷ 6.5, rounded to the nearest $0.01. It is checked weekly and applies from the start of the next settlement week."
This names the source, sets a band, states the formula, and says when a change takes effect. Have your own advisor review any pay agreement before you use it.
Step 4: Get percentage pay right
On percentage pay, the question is not "did diesel move?" but "what does the percentage apply to?" Three common setups:
Linehaul only, fuel surcharge passed through. A load bills $2,200: $1,900 linehaul plus a $300 fuel surcharge. At 28% of linehaul, the driver earns $532, plus the $300 surcharge if the agreement passes it through: $832. The common mistake is applying 28% to the full $2,200 ($616) and also passing through the surcharge, or applying 28% to $2,200 and passing nothing. Each is a different number from what the agreement says.
Percentage after fuel and trip costs. An 800-mile load pays $2,000. At 6 MPG it burns about 133 gallons. With $80 in tolls:
| Diesel $3.80 | Diesel $4.30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | $506.67 | $573.33 |
| Net after fuel and tolls | $1,413.33 | $1,346.67 |
| Driver at 25% of net | $353.33 | $336.67 |
The driver's pay drops about $17 on this load, and the carrier's share drops about $50. That is the formula working, but only if the agreement says pay is figured on the net.
Percentage of gross. Pay ignores fuel completely, and the carrier carries every cent of a spike.
Whatever you use, write it down. Many fleets on percentage pay also set a weekly minimum so a bad freight week doesn't push pay below a set amount. A minimum that only appears when a driver complains is a favor, not a rule.
Step 5: When diesel drops
A fuel surcharge moves both ways. When diesel falls toward the baseline, the surcharge shrinks, sometimes to zero. Using the step table above, a driver goes from $0.64 to $0.60 a mile when diesel drops from $4.10 to $3.70.
Nothing unfair happened. But a driver who only sees a smaller number on Friday will think the rate was cut. So:
- Tell drivers before the statement, not after: "Diesel averaged $3.70 this week, down from $4.10, so the fuel line moves from 6¢ to 2¢ a mile."
- Show the baseline, the current price, and the formula.
- Name the public source so drivers can check it.
- Use the same channel every time.
Step 6: Change pay forward, at a clear boundary
The rule that prevents most disputes: never apply a new fuel number to miles already run. Pick one of these and use it every time:
| When the change applies | How it works | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Per load | Surcharge locked to the price on the day the load is dispatched | Short spot runs |
| Each settlement week | One price per week, set at the weekly cutoff | Most fleets paying weekly |
| Review window in the contract | Reset every 2–4 weeks per a clause | Dedicated lanes, contract freight |
For each change, keep: the old rate, the new rate, the price and source used, the date it took effect, and who approved it. With that record, a driver's question takes five minutes, not a week of digging.
A practical routine for each settlement week:
- Pull the reference price from your named source and region.
- Check the baseline on file. Many errors come from using this week's formula with an old baseline.
- Apply the formula to miles run in the new period only.
- Tell dispatch and the drivers before the statement goes out.
- Have a person review the statement before it is approved.
- Save the price, date, and formula with the statement.
For a full pre-pay check of a statement, see How to Audit Driver Settlements for Accuracy Before Payment. For how deductions should appear, see How to Calculate Driver Settlement Deductions the Right Way.
IFTA is a separate number
A fuel surcharge is driver pay. IFTA is fuel tax based on gallons and miles by state. They often use the same receipts, so record each fuel purchase once and let both read it, but don't use one to set the other. See IFTA When Diesel Prices Swing.
Common questions
Should I raise the base rate when diesel spikes? Usually no. Drivers read a base-rate cut later as a pay cut. Keep the base steady and let the fuel line move.
How often should the surcharge change? Match your settlement cycle, usually weekly, and only when the price crosses a band.
Can I apply a new fuel rate to last week's loads? Don't. Apply it from a clear date forward and tell drivers which days it covers.
Does a fuel surcharge change my IFTA return? No. IFTA follows gallons and miles by state.
How Yolda handles the statement side
In Yolda's driver settlement software, you pick a driver and Yolda writes their weekly statement from the loads they ran. Each load is priced by the pay agreement that was in force when it was delivered, with bonuses, deductions, reimbursements, and advances included. Who pays a fuel or toll charge comes from the pay agreement, not a checkbox.
When you change a driver's pay terms, the change applies from its effective date forward. Statements nobody has approved yet are updated to the new terms; a statement waiting for review goes back for a fresh review. Approved and paid statements stay exactly as they were.
A person reviews and approves every statement. Approving emails each driver their own PDF, and drivers can open it in the app. Every statement shows the rate each load paid and the loaded and empty miles the driver's pay was built from. Your company pays drivers through its usual payroll or bank process and records the payment in Yolda.
Checklist: fuel-ready driver pay
- Name your pay model and where diesel hits it.
- Set a baseline price and a public reference (EIA weekly, your region).
- Choose a band (5¢ or 10¢) and a formula, with rounding.
- Decide how empty miles and reefer fuel are handled.
- On percentage pay, write down exactly what the percentage applies to.
- Apply changes forward from a settlement boundary only.
- Tell drivers before the statement, with the math.
- Keep the old rate, new rate, price, date, and approver for every change.
- Review every statement before it is approved.



